The term, never before used in philosophy, 1 is clearly a polemical transformation of spinoza s amor dei intellectualis, rejecting the primacy of the intellect and positing fatum fate instead of spinoza s naturegod as the object of love. Relying on a meticulous and careful reading of the theologicalpolitical treatise and the ethics, this book reconstructs spinoza s philosophy of contradictions as a key to the ascending three degrees of knowledge leading to the amor intellectualis dei. In the third part, i will attempt to rework spinozas amor dei intellectualis from his definitions of love and the other affects in part three of the ethics. In the first part of this article, i will explain some of the problems surrounding this notion, and then turn, in the second part, to consider two unsatisfactory solutions. In the book, strauss identified spinoza as part of the tradition of enlightenment rationalism that eventually produced modernity. Poem written in 1937 in prison prior to execution by stalin.
His belief is that the ultimate aim for humankind is the intellectual love of god or the amor dei intellectualis, which is equivalent to knowledge of god, that this knowledge of the natural causal order is the only true religion and a route to freedom. Materializing spinozas account of human freedom julie r. Spinozas jewishness by our readers, commentary magazine. However, formatting rules can vary widely between applications and fields of interest or study. Amor fati love of fate is the defiant formula by which nietzsche sums up his philosophical affirmation. At the very beginning of book i of the ethics, spinoza gives a definition of freedom. Many would stretch this period one generation further and to include hume, locke and berkeley. It is scientia intuitiva, part of the amor intellectualis dei, which, though. The fifth and final chapter addresses spinoza s notion of amor dei intellectualis. A century after spinoza hume is less optimistic about this idea of philosophy understood as a medicina mentis. Spinoza is commonly perceived as the great metaphysician of coherence. Published in rosa mystica, poem in 1881, the title of this poem refers to baruch spinozas, a 17th century religious philosopher and his doctrine of amor dei intellectualis.
A novel about philosophy, and the amor dei intellectualis. The book is marked by the freshness of an independently thinking mind. Read the role of contradictions in spinoza s philosophy the godintoxicated heretic by yuval jobani available from rakuten kobo. Jewish thinkers, though, had a much more ambivalent attitude about this issue.
If you want to study spinoza, this is the first book id advise you to read. Amor dei intellectualis baruch spinoza, in the prison poems of nikolai bukharin. Unlike other pleasures, it can be renewed without limit. He suggests that spinoza was influenced by the kabbalah regarding his expressions deus sive natura and amor dei intellectualis. In accordance with the wishes of his father he studied theology, but soon showed a decided preference for free philosophical speculation. Part of the martinus nijhoff philosophy library book series mnpl, volume.
The notion of divine love was essential to medieval christian conceptions of god. The role of contradictions in spinozas philosophy routledge. The role of contradictions in spinozas philosophy ebook by. Amor dei intellectualis, it even transcends human finitude and becomes a form of salvation beatitudo. In the course of his studies on kabbalah, moshe idel has written on the influence of kabbalists on philosophy.
Considered in this impersonal light, mans highest good, accessible only to an elite few, is shown to be the knowledge of god, which itself yields to an exalted, unrequited love amor dei intellectualis. Ages, and about people, translated by george shriver seagull books, calcutta india, 2009, pp. Transformation of the world verse about the ages, and about people, translated by george shriver seagull books, calcutta india, 2009, pp. Spinoza s idea of love of godnature is in my eyes the rarest and most precious pearl of the ethics 106. Freedom, action, and motivation in spinozas ethics. In the third part, i will attempt to rework spinozas amor dei intellectualis from his. Leo strauss dedicated his first book, spinozas critique of religion, to an examination of the latters ideas. Some of us are funky, some of us technowizards, some of us are mods and throwbackers and vintagers, or even beats. Moreover, spinoza shares the idea of the intellectual union with god with maimonides, who anticipated the philosopher of amsterdam in proclaiming the intellect the highest good. I also read his other books on spinoza, youll like his way of explaining. The materialist interpretation of spinozas ontology, that was almost unani mous since the beginning of the 18th century, was founded. Finally, if spinozas radicalism naturalizes god and man, it also secularizes politics. Pdf the true religion and the philosophical god of spinoza. Show full abstract recapturing reciprocity as at the end of spinoza s ethics.
Nietzsches note is based on a chapter in fischers book entitled teleology. In other words, the amor dei intellectualis is the dopamine hit which characterizes an aha moment. The thcentury ecstatic kabbalist rabbi abraham abulafia and. The philosophy of spinoza alfred weber b aruch benedict spinoza,1 spinosa, or despinoza, was born at amsterdam, in 1632, of portuguese jewish parents, who were, it seems, in good circumstances. Spinoza on human freedoms and the eternity of the mind noa naamanzauderer. Spinoza tried to replace the bible with a scientificallybased ethical system. And if the mark of a personal being is that it is one towards which we can entertain personal attitudes, then we should note too that spinoza recommends amor intellectualis dei the intellectual love of god as the supreme good for man 5p33. There seems to be a connection to nietzsches knowledge of spinoza here as well. Spinozas is one of the best of all these books, at least of the. A portrait of spinoza as a maimonidean reconsidered. The former was published during his lifetime, but the latter, which contains the entirety of his philosophical system in its most rigorous form, was not published until after his death in 1677. Amor dei intellectualis baruch spinoza the autodidact project.
Pdf the enigma of spinozas amor dei intellectualis. Spinoza famously labels the fundamental emotion, which man experiences when he accurately perceives the essence of universal nature, amor dei intellectualis, the intellectual love of god. Nadler is one of the best living spinoza interpretors. The role of contradictions in spinozas philosophy the god. In the event things got worse, and spinoza gave up the idea of publishing the ethics, believing that it would create such a cloud of hostility as to obscure, in the minds even of reasonable people, the real meaning of its arguments. In the famous conclusion to book i of his treatise, having established the antimetaphysical framework of the science of. The role of contradictions in spinozas philosophy by yuval. This eternal love is a bliss that sees god or nature. Jan 29, 2016 relying on a meticulous and careful reading of the theologicalpolitical treatise and the ethics, this book reconstructs spinoza s philosophy of contradictions as a key to the ascending three degrees of knowledge leading to the amor intellectualis dei. The term, never before used in philosophy, 1 is clearly a polemical transformation of spinozas amor dei intellectualis, rejecting the primacy of the intellect and positing fatum fate instead of spinozas naturegod as the object of love. The terminology involved is traced to the sequence of alfarabi, ibn sina, maimonides, gersonides, and thus to spinoza, who is credited with making the.
Religio vera is not to cognize god, but to maintain everyday morality and social order. Jul 03, 2017 the scope of beltrans study is quite wide, covering diverse issues such as amor dei intellectualis, the notion of causa sui, the nature of the attributes, infinity, and acosmism. A novel about philosophy, and the amor dei intellectualis steven h. Third, it is worth thinking about the relation between nietzsches amor fati and spinoza s amor dei intellectualis, because both conceptions try to formulate an answer to the question how to deal with the historicity of the human existence. Strangely enough beyond a classical amor dei in which god does not answer our love, i. The book also contains some insightful discussions of spinozas reception of maimonides and of wachters reading of spinoza. Jun 12, 2015 philosophy baruch spinoza the school of life.
Download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. Relying on a meticulous and careful reading of the theologicalpolitical treatise and the ethics, this book reconstructs spinoza s philosophy of contradictions as a key to the ascending three. The phrase is elevated in ethics part five, and has been shown to derive from the treatment by maimonides in his guide for the perplexed. Pdf the enigma of spinozas amor dei intellectualis yitzhak y. While maimonides was reluctant to ascribe love, or any other affect, to god, gersonides.
Spinozas philosophy encompasses nearly every area of philosophical discourse, including. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading the book of god. It is through this untiring bond of devotion that enables man to attain his greatest. Spinoza on the right way to live offices and directory. The terminology involved is traced to the sequence of alfarabi, ibn sina, maimonides, gersonides, and thus to spinoza, who is credited with making the strongest effort to endow this concept with philosophical clarity harvey 2014. Spinoza on the right way to live gary zabel like plato, aristotle, epicurus and most other ancient philosophers, spinoza sets for philosophy a very elevated goal, namely to guide human beings to the realization of their highest good, or as spinoza also puts it, the ultimate human perfection. Amor intellectualis dei 26 mar 1927 the spectator archive. Amor dei intellectualis baruch spinoza ralph dumain. Moreover, he identifies spinoza and his works as the beginning of jewish modernity.
99 1452 1055 1069 1089 1587 707 1108 816 352 11 1128 568 1496 641 718 1049 313 903 1485 1060 988 1349 1548 176 1415 1503 1303 663 1271 132 341 165 967 271 505 91